FREE TOOL · NO SIGNUP NEEDED

Lapsed Donor Win‑Back Kit

Three emails, a letter, and a call script to bring lapsed donors back, on a dated four-week plan.

A lapsed donor gave to you before but hasn’t given this year. The longer they’re gone, the harder they are to win back: only 3.0% of donors who had stopped giving for a year or more came back in 2025 (Fundraising Effectiveness Project). This kit writes a short win-back series from your answers: thank them, show what changed, make one clear ask, and ask why they stopped.

1

Your lapsed donors

Pick who you're writing to. The numbers are optional and show what winning donors back is worth.

2

What you want to say

Lead with what happened since they last gave. Short and specific beats long and general.

3

Your win-back kit

Written from your answers. Merge fields like [First name] fill in from your donor database or email tool.

4

Your schedule

Four weeks, start to finish. Stop sending to anyone who gives.

    Before you send

      NextSee how many donors you keep each year with the Donor Retention Calculator.

      Keep your kit

      Your kit saves in this browser. Print it to share with your team, or copy the link to finish on another computer.

      Get your printable kit

      Enter your email to unlock:

      • Your dated schedule, all three emails, the letter, and the call and text scripts on one printout to share with your team
      • A link back to this page. Your kit stays saved in the browser you used.

      Free. We'll also send occasional fundraising tips. Unsubscribe anytime.

      Three steps

      How to win back lapsed donors

      Thank first, ask clearly, and listen to what they tell you.

      1. 1

        Pull a clean list

        Start with donors who gave last year but not this year, then older donors. Leave out anyone who asked not to be contacted, and update moved addresses before you mail.

      2. 2

        Thank before you ask

        Open with what their past gift did and what’s happened since. Send from a real person, and make one clear ask with one link.

      3. 3

        Follow up, then listen

        Use email, mail, and a few calls over four weeks. Ask why they stopped, stop the series for anyone who gives, and thank them within two days.

      Questions

      Lapsed donor FAQ

      What is a lapsed donor?

      A donor who gave to you before but hasn’t given in your current year. Many teams split them into donors who gave last year but not this year (often called LYBUNT) and donors who gave in an earlier year but not this one (SYBUNT).

      How many lapsed donors come back?

      Not many on their own, once they’ve been gone a full year. In 2025, 3.0% of previously inactive donors gave again, across the nonprofits in the Fundraising Effectiveness Project. Donors who gave last year are much easier to keep, so reach them first. A planned series of thank-yous and asks gives more of yours a reason to return.

      What should a lapsed donor email say?

      Thank them, show what’s happened since their last gift, and make one clear ask with one link. Ask why they stopped, and make it easy to reply. Keep it short and send it from a person.

      Should I mail a letter too?

      Mail reaches donors whose email changed or who don’t open email. Before you mail, check addresses against the post office’s change-of-address list (NCOA) so letters reach people who moved.

      Who should get a phone call?

      Your largest lapsed donors and anyone who gave for several years. Call to thank them, not to ask. Ask what changed, listen, and only make the ask if they’re open to it.

      Is this win-back kit free?

      Yes. The emails, letter, call script, and schedule are free with no signup. Enter your email to unlock a printable kit to share with your team.

      Keep more donors with CauseVox

      A donor CRM that shows who lapsed and who gave again, with monthly giving and email built in. Free to start, no credit card required.

      See how CauseVox works for year-end, recurring giving, and donation forms.